Reviewer Recognition & SSO
Get verified credit to ORCID and Web of Science (formerly Publons) after a confidential review — without compromising anonymity.
TL;DR
- Opt-in once in your reviewer profile using SSO (ORCID login). We’ll only send credit with your permission.
- Your review stays confidential. We record the fact you reviewed for a journal and date/year — not manuscript titles or authors.
- Two destinations: ORCID (Peer Review section) and Web of Science (Reviewer Recognition on your researcher profile).
- Zero extra forms: credit is sent automatically after the editorial decision, or you can claim via a one-click email link.
Why recognition matters (and how it eases the reviewer crunch)
Reviewers give time, expertise, and focus. Verified recognition turns that invisible labor into CV-visible, machine-verifiable credit. Departments can see your service; funders recognize community contribution; and journals build a larger, more motivated reviewer pool. In our pilots, simply adding recognition increased reviewer acceptance and on-time completion.
How recognition & SSO work together
1) Single Sign-On (SSO) with ORCID
Sign in using your ORCID iD. During setup you can grant our system the permission to add peer-review activity to your ORCID record. You can revoke that permission anytime in ORCID.
2) Decision-triggered credit
After the editor makes a decision, our system sends a minimal, non-identifying record to the destinations you picked. If you prefer email claims, you’ll receive a message with a one-click “Add to Profile” link.
What we send (and what we never send)
Field | Sent to ORCID | Sent to Web of Science | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Reviewer identity | ORCID iD | Name + email (for matching/claim) | Identity is required to attribute credit. |
Journal | Journal title | Journal title | Shown publicly on your profiles. |
Role & type | Peer reviewer; blind status | Peer reviewer | No manuscript identifiers. |
Date | Year (or date range) | Month/Year | Exact dates may be generalized. |
Manuscript title/authors | Not sent | Not sent | Confidentiality preserved. |
Recommendation text | Not sent | Not sent | Review content stays private. |
We follow a “minimum necessary data” principle: only the fields required to verify your review service are transmitted.
Step-by-step: add verified credit to your profiles
A) Connect ORCID and turn on auto-credit (recommended)
- Open your Reviewer Profile and choose Sign in with ORCID.
- When prompted, grant permission for us to “Add items to your ORCID record” (you can revoke later in ORCID → Trusted organizations).
- Tick the checkbox Send peer-review credit to my ORCID.
- Complete your next review as usual. After the editor’s decision, we’ll add an entry to your ORCID Peer review section automatically.
B) Add credit to Web of Science (formerly Publons)
You have two options—pick the one you prefer:
- Claim by email (no setup): After the decision, you’ll receive an email titled “Claim your review”. Click the secure link to add the review to your Web of Science Researcher Profile.
- Connect once, then auto-credit: In your Reviewer Profile → Recognition, link your Web of Science account. Once linked, we’ll deliver credit automatically after each completed review.
Example timeline: Priya’s first review with recognition
Confidentiality & ethics
Recognition is never a back door to reveal manuscript content. We do not send manuscript titles, author names, recommendations, or text from your report. Credit reflects your service as a reviewer, not the details of the paper.
SSO: what it is and why it helps
Single Sign-On (SSO) lets you use one trusted identity across our sites. We support ORCID login, which means:
- Fewer passwords to manage; your ORCID iD becomes the anchor for recognition.
- Cleaner metadata (your name, affiliations, and identifiers are consistent).
- Permission-based automation: with your consent, we can add peer-review items to your ORCID and deliver recognition to Web of Science.
What if… (edge cases & how to fix them)
I reviewed anonymously. Can I still get credit?
Yes. Recognition covers that you reviewed for a journal and when — not who or what you reviewed. Your anonymity remains intact.
The email to claim my Web of Science credit expired.
Open your Reviewer Profile → Recognition and click Resend claim link, or link your account for automatic delivery next time.
I connected ORCID but nothing appears.
ORCID only receives reviews after an editorial decision. If a submission is still in progress, no record will be posted yet. Also check ORCID → Trusted organizations to confirm you granted “Add items” permission.
I don’t want credit for a particular review.
No problem. Untick the recognition checkbox at the time of review, or set your default to “Ask me every time” in profile settings.
Can editors see my ORCID-linked reviews?
Editors see standard workflow activity. Your public ORCID/Web of Science profiles show only the minimal, non-identifying record of service.
The data path (for the curious)
We send the smallest possible payload to attribute credit while protecting confidentiality.
{
"destination": "ORCID",
"reviewer": "https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1825-0097",
"journal": "Example Journal",
"role": "reviewer",
"reviewType": "double-blind",
"date": "2025",
"visibility": "public"
}
{
"destination": "Web of Science",
"reviewerEmail": "[email protected]",
"journal": "Example Journal",
"date": "2025-07",
"claimLink": "https://… (single-use, time-limited)"
}
FAQ
Is this compatible with my institution’s policies?
Yes. Recognition logs service; it does not reveal manuscript details and aligns with common promotion and tenure CV formats.
Will this affect double-blind review?
No. Nothing about the manuscript’s identity is disclosed in recognition feeds.
Can I remove a review from my profiles?
You control visibility. Hide or remove items in ORCID/Web of Science, or revoke our permission at any time.
Copy-paste snippets for your profile & emails
Profile toggle label
“Send my verified peer-review credit to ORCID and Web of Science after a decision. I understand no manuscript details are shared.”
Decision email footer
“Thank you for reviewing. With your permission, we can add verified credit to your ORCID and Web of Science profiles. Learn how or manage preferences in your Reviewer Profile.”
Good to know
- Recognition is optional and off by default unless you switch it on.
- If multiple emails are associated with your Web of Science account, use the same one in your reviewer profile to avoid mismatches.
- If an editor cancels a review or the paper is withdrawn, no credit is sent.